Viking Blog / History & Finds
The Knowledge Archive

The Victohali: a People Known Almost Only as a Name

History & Finds The Victohali: a People Known Almost Only as a Name

They appear in a list of peoples from the Marcomannic Wars, then again in Eutropius and Ammianus, and between the two lies a gap of more than a century. Anyone who wants to describe the Victohali, also called Victuali, has four or five passages to work with. This article lays them side by side, tests what they can carry and says plainly where the record stops.

A People in a Few Lines

Some peoples of antiquity have a history. Others have a name. The Victohali belong to the second kind. Roman authors mention them only in lists and subordinate clauses: in connection with Marcus Aurelius' wars on the Danube in the second century, and then, at the end of the third and in the fourth century, once more on the lower Danube and the plains to its east. No speech, no named leader, no battle that is explicitly credited to them. No author describes their customs, gods or weapons.

That does not make them unimportant. Precisely because they survive almost only as a name, they show how we know the history of the "Germanic" peoples at all: from keywords that Roman writers noted when a tribe briefly entered their field of view. They also lead into one of scholarship's long-running arguments, namely whether a name that surfaces on the middle Danube in the second century and far to the east in the fourth refers to the same group at all.

The honest balance up front: the sources on the Victohali alone are not enough for an article of this length. So we work more broadly. We go through the name forms, assess the few texts critically, describe the Marcomannic Wars as the frame, introduce the neighbours and explain which interpretations scholars consider. Where something is a guess, it is labelled as one.

Name Forms: Victuali, Victohali and the Others

Tradition knows several spellings. The Historia Augusta, a late antique collection of imperial biographies, calls the people "Victuali" in David Magie's English version. Eutropius, a fourth-century historian, has "Victoali" in John Selby Watson's translation. Ammianus Marcellinus, the last great Latin historian of antiquity, lists "Victohali". Modern reference works add Victovali, Victufali and Victabali. Greek forms rendered as "Biktoa" or "Biktoloi" also turn up in the literature. I could not establish, in the summaries I saw, which text carries these Greek forms. That is a gap.

Variants like these are normal for peripheral peoples. Roman writers heard names from traders, soldiers or envoys, wrote them down by ear, bent them towards familiar Latin patterns, and later copyists made things worse. The spelling "Victuali" recalls the Latin word victualis, "belonging to sustenance", the source of English "victuals". Whether a scribe assimilated the foreign name to this common word cannot be proved. It is one possibility among several.

I know of no secure etymology. Some suggestions found online read the first syllable as "victory" or "fight". I have seen no sound scholarly argument for that and do not pass it on as fact. Even whether the name is Germanic remains open. Wikipedia speaks cautiously of a "possibly Germanic" people, and that caution is justified.

Who Writes When? The Sources at a Glance

Before reading individual passages, look at the framework. There are four groups of texts that name the people. They come from very different periods, and none was written as an eyewitness account of the Victohali themselves.

It is striking that the classic sources for the Marcomannic Wars do not mention the Victohali. Cassius Dio, whose books 72 and 73 supply the main thread, tells of Marcomanni, Quadi, Iazyges and others. According to the summaries I could consult, he does not name the Victohali. That is an argument from silence, and such arguments are weak. Dio survives only in excerpts and fragments, so we do not know whether he never mentioned them or whether the passage was lost.

One correction to what is sometimes read: the geographer Ptolemy (second century) does not list the Victohali in the roster of Sarmatia in his Geography (3.5), as far as I checked. Between the Vistula and Dacia it names, among others, Burgiones, Anartophracti, Peucini, Bastarnae and Coestoboci, but no name like Victuali or Biktouali. I did not go through the Germany chapters (2.11) name by name. So it cannot be shown that Ptolemy knew the Victohali, and I do not treat him as a source for them.

The Historia Augusta: the Victuali in the Border Chaos

The earliest mention stands in the Life of Marcus Antoninus, that is, Marcus Aurelius. In chapter 14, in David Magie's English translation (Loeb 1921), it says that not only the Victuali and the Marcomanni were throwing everything into confusion. The sentence goes on to other tribes that had been driven out by more remote barbarians and were pressing into the empire unless admitted. Behind it stands an image that still occupies scholars: pressure from outside setting peoples in motion and pushing them against the imperial frontier.

The second passage is in chapter 22. It says that all peoples from the Illyrian frontier to Gaul had conspired: the Marcomanni, Varistae, Hermunduri and Quadi, the Suebi, Sarmatians, Lacringes and Buri, these and some others together with the Victuali. A further run of names follows, including the Costoboci. The exact names in that second run are badly garbled in the manuscripts. Magie renders them as Osi, Bessi and Cobotes; other editions read them differently. I could not consult the Latin wording for this article because the sites offering it were unreachable behind the proxy. The Latin spellings here are therefore inferred from secondary literature and translations.

How much is this list worth? Scholars handle it with care. Our page on the Lacringi already places the passage once: as a "table of peoples" compiled by a late fourth-century author from older material. Whether the source was a contemporary report is open. The Historia Augusta cites sources for some claims that cannot be traced. So for the Victuali: they are credible as part of the coalition against Rome because other, independent texts later know the same name. That certainty, however, covers only the name. What the Historia Augusta says about their role is weakly supported.

The Marcomannic Wars as the Frame

To see where the Victuali stand in history, one has to know the war in which they appear. The Marcomannic Wars (roughly 166 to 180) were the most dangerous crisis on the Danube the Roman Empire had faced in a long time. The key dates follow as given in the Wikipedia summary; every dating is disputed in detail by scholars and serves here only as orientation.

The Victuali are a footnote in this scaffold. That the Historia Augusta names them in the withdrawals of 168 is the only piece of action one can assign to them. Everything else is frame, and the frame belongs to Marcomanni and Quadi. Our pages on the Marcomanni and the Quadi tell more about them.

Who the Neighbours Were

When a people says so little itself, the company it keeps helps. The Historia Augusta's table of peoples contains several names we have treated elsewhere.

The Marcomanni and Quadi are the core powers on the Danube frontier. The Marcomanni lived in what is now Bohemia, the Quadi east of them, in the area of Moravia and western Slovakia. Both had long stood in shifting dependence on Rome before the relationship broke. The Hermunduri are another tribe of the region; more on our page on the Hermunduri. Lacringi and Hasdingi appear in the context of the Vandal group (see Lacringi and Hasdingi). The Buri (Buri) are placed by Tacitus in the uplands behind the Marcomanni and Quadi; in the war accounts they appear as a party to the fighting. The Naristi (Naristi) and the Cotini (Cotini) are among the peoples named in the early-170s campaigns. The Sarmatians, above all the Iazyges, form the eastern opponent.

That the Victuali stand in this series suggests a position in the middle Danube region, most likely north or north-east of the Marcomanni and Quadi. The text allows no more. Anyone who places them firmly in Bohemia, Slovakia or Transylvania goes beyond the sources.

Eutropius: a Name in One Sentence about Dacia

The second mention comes from a quite different context. In his outline of Roman history, Eutropius summarises Trajan's conquest of Dacia. The emperor, he says, created a province beyond the Danube, in territory held in Eutropius' own day by other peoples. Here is the wording in John Selby Watson's public-domain English translation (1886), which I read via a lookup page:

"… in that territory which the Thaiphali, Victoali, and Thervingi now occupy."Eutropius, Breviarium 8.2, translated by John Selby Watson (1886), clause only; Latin wording not read by me

This is a location statement for the fourth century: former Roman Dacia, roughly Transylvania and its surroundings, is in the hands of three groups. The Taifali and the Thervingi are familiar from Gothic and Danubian history. The Victoali stand in line with them.

Two cautions. First, Eutropius does not say since when they have been there. Second, it is unclear whether he means the situation of his own time or repeats older knowledge. According to the literature on which the summaries draw, some scholars place the Victohali around the rivers Tisza and Someș (Szamos). That is an interpretation arising from Eutropius and other passages, not a word of the source.

Mamertinus and the Question of the "Vandals"

The panegyric of Claudius Mamertinus on Maximian tells of Thervingi and Taifali fighting "Vandals" and Gepids. The orator writes in 291 or shortly after. For some time it has been debated whether "Vandals" in this passage could be a scribal error for Victohali. The argument rests on location: some seek the Victohali in the Tisza and Someș area, next to Thervingi and Taifali, whereas the far-off Vandals do not fit there. A conjecture, that is, a proposed correction of a supposed error, cannot be proved. I have not read the speech myself and know the discussion only from summarising secondary literature. Anyone repeating it should label it a proposal, not a finding.

Ammianus: Refugees among the Victohali

The fullest passage comes from Ammianus Marcellinus in book 17. He tells the prehistory of the Sarmatians with whom the emperor Constantius II dealt around 358. The masters of the region, he says, had once been powerful and noble. Then their slaves conspired, took up arms and beat them, being just as brave and far more numerous. The defeated fled to the Victohali, who lived "afar off", thinking it better to submit to protectors than to serve slaves. That is how I read John C. Rolfe's English version (1935 to 1940), parts of which I could view on a lookup page.

Who are the refugees? Elsewhere Ammianus calls them Arcaragantes, the "free Sarmatians"; their rebelling slaves are the Limigantes, the "slave Sarmatians". According to the literature, the Limigantes lived on the Tisza in the Banat. Scholars date the uprising to the 330s; 332 to 334 is often given. The emperor who took the Arcaragantes under his protection and made one of their number king was Constantine the Great. The years are modern inferences. Ammianus himself tells it as a flashback.

Two things stand out. First, the aids disagree about where the Victohali of this passage lived. The footnote in the Rolfe edition says they "probably lived in the region of Bohemia". Several overviews, including English Wikipedia, instead have the Arcaragantes flee to a Victohali territory south of the Danube and become their vassals there. Those are two incompatible locations, and both are interpretations of the terse "afar off". Second, the passage shows that around 334 the Victohali were politically capable enough to take in refugees. A protector without strength of its own would not have been a destination. That too is an inference, not wording.

After 357 the reports stop. In the summaries I could consult, the Victohali do not appear again after the events around the Arcaragantes. As far as we can see, the people dissolve into larger groupings. Research summaries name the Ostrogoths and the Hunnic empire. That is not attested; it is the usual explanation for the disappearance of small groups, not a report about the Victohali.

Same Name, Same People? The Continuity Problem

This is the real difficulty. Between the Historia Augusta, which gives the name for the 160s, and Eutropius, Mamertinus and Ammianus lie 120 to 200 years. In that time groups move over large distances, split, merge, adopt names and drop them. A name that appears on the middle Danube in Marcus Aurelius' time and in the fourth century far to the east can designate the same group. It can also have been borne by another group that inherited it, or have been part of an alliance named after one component.

Research on ethnogenesis, the formation of "peoples", has stressed this since the mid-twentieth century. Reinhard Wenskus laid the foundation in 1961 with the idea that the tribes of the migration age were not closed descent communities but groups gathered around a core of tradition. Applied to the Victohali this gives an uncomfortable result: that their name survives for centuries says nothing about kinship. It says only that somewhere the memory of the name was handed on.

Against this stands the simple reading often presented in handbooks as self-evident: a people that moves east after the Marcomannic War and settles in Dacia in the third century. That reading is possible and is occasionally advanced. It cannot be proved, because for the period between about 170 and 290 not a single text mentions the Victohali. This near-century of silence is no accident; it is the biggest problem of the whole question.

Were the Victohali Vandals?

A widespread guess counts the Victohali among the "Vandili", the grouping to which Hasdingi, Silingi, Lacringi, Helvecones and Naharnavali are assigned. English Wikipedia mentions this attribution cautiously. It is a summary, not a specialist study, and it formulates a possibility, not a secure assignment.

What speaks for it? In the Historia Augusta the Victuali stand directly beside Lacringi and Buri, that is, beside groups otherwise named in the Vandals' orbit. Against it: no ancient author explicitly counts the Victohali among the Vandals. Whoever does infers from neighbours in a list and from geography, both weak grounds. The same applies to the assumption that they were Germanic at all. Compare the Cotini, for whom Tacitus expressly mentions a non-Germanic language. For the Victohali we have no statement on language whatsoever, neither Germanic nor otherwise.

What is secure

  • The name appears in several ancient texts: in the Historia Augusta (Marcus Antoninus 14 and 22), in Eutropius, in Ammianus Marcellinus and, if one accepts the conjecture, in Mamertinus. The spelling varies.
  • The Historia Augusta places them beside the Marcomanni and other opponents of Marcus Aurelius. That they stand in this list is certain; their role in the war is not.
  • Ammianus reports refugees who put themselves under the Victohali and were taken under Constantine's protection. The date is modern inference (about 332 to 334).
  • For the third century there is no report about them.

Myth check

  • "The Victohali were certainly a Germanic tribe." This cannot be shown. No ancient source gives their language. The classification is a guess based on name form and neighbours in lists.
  • "Ptolemy describes their territory." The name is absent from the Sarmatia roster of the Geography (3.5), and I found no other Ptolemy passage that names it. The claim cannot be confirmed.
  • "They founded a great kingdom in Dacia." Eutropius merely lists them beside Taifali and Thervingi as occupants of the territory. There is no word of a kingdom of their own, a king or a capital.
  • "The name means victory people." This reading circulates online; I have found it in no scholarly source. It is unsupported.

What Remains Open

Unknown are the Victohali's homeland in the second century, language, size, leadership, religion and social order. It is also unclear whether the name means the same group in every text. Archaeologically, no find group can be securely tied to them; assignments of this kind that one sometimes reads rest on an assumed location and are not finds with a name tag. Anyone wanting to know more needs new texts, for example a better reading of the Historia Augusta manuscripts, or new arguments about the position of the Thervingi and Taifali. Until then the most honest description stays the same: a name from Marcus Aurelius' list of peoples that turns up once more on the Danube in the fourth century.

Frequently asked questions

How is the name spelled correctly? There is no single correct form. Sources and translations offer Victuali, Victoali, Victohali and further variants. In scholarship "Victohali" (after Ammianus) is common; in German one also reads Victualen.

Were the Victohali Vandals or Goths? Neither can be proved. Some accounts count them among the Vandals, but no ancient source says so explicitly. They are linked to the Goths only through the neighbourhood in Eutropius.

Did the Victohali fight Rome? The Historia Augusta lists them among the opponents in the Marcomannic Wars. No single battle is credited to them. How strongly they took part, we do not know.

Where did they live? That is open. For the second century lists point to the middle Danube, while a footnote to Ammianus names Bohemia. For the late third and fourth centuries some connect them with Dacia and the Tisza-Someș area.

Is there a connection with the Viktualienmarkt? No; that would be a chance resemblance. German "Viktualien" comes from Latin victualia, provisions. A link to the people's name is not attested.

Further reading on this site

birch slice Yggdrasil (Ø 32–34 cm)
From our workshop: birch slice “Yggdrasil” (Ø 32–34 cm) – laser-engraved on real wood, hand-sanded and oiled. To the shop →

Read more with us

The Marcomanni · The Quadi · The Vandals · The Lacringi · The Hasdingi.

Sources & literature

Visit the Shop More posts

More from History & Finds

All History & Finds articles →

The Vidivarii: A Union at the Vistula Mouth

Two sentences in Jordanes, and that is all: the Vidivarii sit where the Vistula runs into the sea in three branches …

Read more →

The Vindelev Gold Hoard – Bracteates, Runes and a Chieftain Who Buried His Gold

In December 2020 a metal detector sounded in a field at Vindelev in eastern Jutland, a few kilometres from Jelling …

Read more →

The Vindelici – Celts Between Lake Constance, Danube and Inn, and the End of Their Independence

The Vindelici were a group of Celtic, perhaps partly Raetian-influenced peoples in the northern Alpine foreland …

Read more →

The year 1021: three pieces of wood, a radiation event and the limits of a famous date

Since October 2021 a single date has run through writing on the Vikings in America: 1021. It comes from no saga and no …

Read more →