Viking Blog / History & Finds
The Knowledge Archive

Horik I: The Danish King Whom Franks and Missionaries Negotiated With

History & Finds Horik I: The Danish King Whom Franks and Missionaries Negotiated With

For decades Horik I was the Franks' contact in the north. He sent envoys, broke a promise, claimed to have executed raiders and allowed the missionary Ansgar to build a church at the trading place on the Schlei. In 845, according to the Annals of St-Bertin, he sent 600 ships up the Elbe and lost. In 854 he died fighting relatives. No Danish record from his time survives; everything we know comes from Frankish writers and a missionary's biography. This article separates what those texts say, what scholars infer and what is later legend.

A king we only see from outside

Horik I is one of the few Danish kings of the ninth century who appear by name in several sources. Even so, he is hard to grasp. No rune stone names him, no coin carries his name, and no Danish chronicle from his lifetime exists. We see the Danish court only through the eyes of outsiders: annalists at the Frankish court, monks, and a missionary who was his guest.

The Franks cared about Horik where he touched their northern border: boundary questions, raids on Frisia, embassies. Rimbert, the biographer of Ansgar, cared about the prospects of the mission. What Horik himself wanted has to be inferred from what he did, and that remains interpretation.

Classification matters too. Horik is not a saga hero; Iceland does not know him, and according to the English Wikipedia the Icelandic king lists omit him. He is a Danish king, a rex in the Latin texts, whose realm bordered the Frankish Empire and the Saxons. That Norsemen raided Frankish coasts in the ninth century does not make him the leader of those raids. For the people, see the article on the Danes; for the wider setting, the article on Nordic kings.

Two Horiks, one name

Writers often mix up two kings of the same name. This article is about Horik I, who ruled until 854. His namesake Horik II was king after 854. He was a child then and survived the fighting that, according to the English Wikipedia, wiped out nearly all royal lines. The same page mentions a letter from Pope Nicholas I in 864 urging him to accept baptism; I know that only from that summary.

How the two were related is not recorded. Wikipedia calls it possible that Horik II was a nephew or grandson of Horik I and says he was probably not his son. Any family tree built on this ends in conjecture. When a source says "King Horik", ask first which year is meant: up to 854 it is Horik I, afterwards Horik II.

A further tangle concerns the name. In C. H. Robinson's public-domain English translation of Rimbert's Life (1921), the introduction calls the Danish king "Eric King of Jutland", while the translated text writes "Horic". Saxo Grammaticus, writing around 1200, also knows an "Eric", according to the English Wikipedia. The name Horik was reinterpreted as Erik in later Danish tradition, so Horik is sometimes found under another name.

Who writes about Horik

The sources fall into four groups, and they should be kept apart.

Frankish annals. The Annales regni Francorum (Royal Frankish Annals) follow Godfred's sons as opponents of Harald Klak from 813. Horik, as far as I know, first appears by name for 827. The Annales Bertiniani (Annals of St-Bertin), kept from 830 at the court of Louis the Pious and then Charles the Bald, carry the main news for the late 830s and for 845. The Annals of Fulda, written at the court of Louis the German, report among other things Harald and Horik's death. All are court annals: short, written from the Frankish side, silent on whatever did not touch their realm.

Rimbert's Vita Anskarii. Rimbert, later Ansgar's successor as archbishop, wrote the life of his predecessor after Ansgar's death in 865. He was a contemporary with witnesses at hand. The work is a saint's life; it shows Ansgar's achievements and casts Horik as the well-disposed king who permits the mission. It is weak for dates and strong for attitudes and details of the mission.

Monastic literature. Miracle collections, such as those of the monastery of Saint-Germain-des-Prés, tell of the aftermath of the 845 Paris raid and let Horik appear. They are devotional texts and must be read with great care; see the article on Paris 845.

Later authors. Adam of Bremen wrote his church history of Hamburg around 1075, the Dane Saxo Grammaticus the Gesta Danorum around 1200. Both know the period from books and their own constructions. Saxo, who calls Horik "Eric", makes him a brother of Harald Klak according to the English Wikipedia; scholars regard this as a free combination.

I have not read the Latin annals in critical editions; what I write about them rests on translations, quotations and summaries. I know the Rimbert passages from Robinson's translation, as far as a retrieval tool delivered them.

From Godfred's sons to sole ruler

Scholars regard Horik as a son of King Godfred, who died in 810. The English Wikipedia says that of Godfred's at least five sons only Horik is known by name. Speculation about the others has not won acceptance.

After Godfred's death Hemming, a nephew, ruled; in 811 he made peace with the Franks at the Eider and died in 812. A succession dispute followed, which in the end the side of Harald Klak won. According to the Royal Frankish Annals, Godfred's sons returned and drove Harald out, and he found refuge in the Frankish Empire. More than this sketch cannot be said reliably about 813 to 819, and the number of brothers, their order and their territories are open. The English Wikipedia lists a temporary share of power for Harald in 819 to 823; I have not checked that against the annals.

In 826 the picture changes. Harald Klak was baptised at Ingelheim at the court of Louis the Pious, and the emperor tried to support him with a mission to Denmark. Godfred's sons sent envoys with peace offers around the same time. Horik promised to appear before Louis at Nijmegen in 827. He did not come; instead he drove Harald out for good. The sequence is well attested in the annals and described in detail in the article on Harald Klak.

Whether this made Horik sole ruler at once is open. In 828 he and his brother defeated a Frankish force east of the Eider; after that the brother disappears from the sources. That Horik ruled alone from then on is a conjecture based on the annals speaking only of him. Rimbert, in chapter 24, calls him "sole monarch of the Danes" in Robinson's rendering, but that refers to the time around 850, and soon afterwards Horik had to share power.

Envoys, promises and the policy of the open hand

Horik's relation to the Franks cannot be forced into "enemy" or "friend". The sources show a ruler who sent envoys when useful and avoided obligations when they hurt. At its core was the tension between Denmark, Saxony, Frisia and the Slavic Obodrites.

According to Niels Lund's study in Historisk Tidsskrift (2002), which I know only from a summary, Horik wanted to restore the influence his father Godfred had had in the south and east, and had to deal with rivals within the family. That is scholarly interpretation. It fits what the Annals of St-Bertin report for the late 830s: Horik asked Louis the Pious to let him have Frisia and the land of the Obodrites. The emperor found the request so inappropriate that, in the summary's words, he "utterly scorned and ignored it".

Whether the request was serious or a diplomatic trial balloon, we do not know. It shows how Horik saw himself: as a man who could lay claim to areas Godfred had already influenced.

Frisia, Dorestad and the charge of piracy

From the 830s raids hit the Frisian coast. According to the English Wikipedia, which I know here only as a summary of the annals, the trading centre of Dorestad was plundered in 834, 835 and 836, and the island of Walcheren in 837. The annals mostly use the collective word "Northmen". That they were Danes is often assumed; that they were Horik's men, no source says.

That was the core of the diplomatic quarrel. The Franks saw the Danish king as master of all Northmen and demanded that he rein them in. Horik answered in two steps. First he had it said that the robbers were not his men. Then, according to the Annals of St-Bertin as reported by Lund, he claimed to have captured and executed those responsible. Whether that was true cannot be checked. It may have been fact, or a move to present himself to the emperor as a reliable neighbour.

The same double role shows again later. In 847, as the German Wikipedia summarises, Count Cobbo was sent to Denmark to demand compensation, and the three Frankish kings threatened Horik with war if the raids went on. The Franks assumed that a rex could steer his countrymen. Reality was probably different: war bands sailed for their own gain, and a king could at best limit them. That is scholarly reasoning, not a source quotation.

For the Rhine mouth the consequences were concrete. Trading places like Dorestad lay on the border of spheres of power, and men like Rorik, from Harald's circle, who turns up in Frisia around 850, show how intertwined the dynasties of both sides were. More about the people there in the article on the Frisians.

845: the Elbe fleet, Hamburg and Ragnar

The year 845 is the part of Horik's story most overgrown with legend. First the sources. The Annals of St-Bertin say for 845, in Lund's Latin quotation: Nortmannorum rex Horicus sexcentas naves per Albim fluvium in Germaniam adversus Hludovicum dirigit, "Horik, king of the Northmen, sends 600 ships up the Elbe into Germany against Louis" (my rendering). The Saxons, the entry continues, defeated the fleet. Afterwards Horik sent envoys to Louis the German and offered to free all prisoners and return the booty as far as lay in his power.

The number 600 is the annalist's. There are no countable ships to check it, and medieval annals like large numbers to show a threat. For comparison, the fleet that sailed up the Seine to Paris in March 845 is given as 120 ships in the same annals. The 600 ships of the Elbe are therefore not the Paris fleet, although accounts like to merge the two.

Many handbooks present Hamburg as the result of the Elbe campaign. Here the tradition splits. In chapter 16 of the Vita Anskarii Rimbert describes how "pirates" suddenly surrounded the town; Count Bernhar, the prefect of the place, was away, the enemy took the town and plundered it and its surroundings, and the bishop barely escaped without a cloak for his body. That chapter, in translation, names no king. The introduction to the 1921 English edition, by contrast, assigns the attack to "Eric King of Jutland", that is Horik, and the German Wikipedia calls the attribution to Horik uncertain: St-Bertin mentions only a Slavic civitas and names neither Hamburg nor Horik.

Lund reads the sources differently. In his view Horik did not attack Hamburg; rather the Saxons, after defeating the Elbe fleet, took a Slavic town. The unnamed monastery that in a miracle report brings Ragnar's end he takes to be Hamburg, not Saint-Germain. The English Wikipedia offers a third reading: the fleet that plundered Paris might have attacked Hamburg on its way home. All three rest on the same terse sentences. Which is right cannot be established.

What is firm: Hamburg was destroyed, Ansgar's see lost its base, and the seat was moved to Bremen in the following years. The English Wikipedia gives 849 as the year Ansgar became archbishop of Bremen; the exact chronology is not the subject here.

And Ragnar? The Annals of Xanten name a leader Reginheri for the Paris raid, the Annals of Fontenelle a Ragneri. In the miracle reports of Saint-Germain Horik appears as the king who had the survivors beheaded for fear of his life, while sending the Christians in his realm home with honour. That is an edifying story, not a record. According to the German Wikipedia a tradition adds that Cobbo heard Ragnar boast at Horik's court; that is second-hand. Whether Reginheri is the saga hero Ragnar Lodbrok remains disputed; the details of the Paris raid are in the article Paris 845.

What is secure

  • Horik appears by name in the Royal Frankish Annals for 827; he then promised to appear before Emperor Louis at Nijmegen and did not keep the promise (written source, contemporary).
  • The Annals of St-Bertin name for 845 an Elbe fleet of 600 ships under Horik, defeated by the Saxons, followed by envoys and a peace offer (written source, contemporary; the number cannot be checked).
  • Hamburg was raided and destroyed around this time (Rimbert, ch. 16). That Horik launched the attack is an attribution by later authors and scholars.
  • Horik allowed Ansgar a church at Sliaswic and let subjects become Christians (Rimbert, ch. 24). As far as is known he was not baptised himself.
  • Horik fell in 854 fighting relatives (Annals of Fulda, Rimbert, via secondary literature).
  • No archaeological find can be linked to Horik's name.

Ansgar and the church at Sliaswic

The meeting of king and missionary is attested by Rimbert and deserves its own look. Ansgar, made bishop and later archbishop of Hamburg, stood without a town after 845. He used what remained: his tie to Louis the German and the trust of the Danish king. The article on Ansgar shows his path as a whole.

According to Rimbert, chapter 24 in Robinson's translation, Ansgar visited the king repeatedly with gifts and went as King Louis's envoy to negotiate peace between Danes and Saxons. Horik came to trust him and valued his counsel. Ansgar urged him to be baptised; the king replied that the scriptures were good and useful and that he wished to win Christ's favour. Ansgar then asked for a place for a house with priest and church. Horik granted it.

"… allowed him to build a church in a part belonging to his kingdom, called Sliaswic."

Rimbert, Vita Anskarii, ch. 24, public-domain English translation by C. H. Robinson (1921), excerpt

Rimbert calls Sliaswic a trading place. The name is usually referred to the settlement on the Schlei, that is Hedeby and later Schleswig; which of the two is meant, the text does not say. The date is also open. English and German Wikipedia say "around 850", another article on this site "around 852". The source itself does not date the permission to a year.

Horik also allowed anyone who wished to become a Christian to do so. Many were baptised, some at Dorestad or Hamburg. What did not happen is striking: the king himself remained, as far as is known, a heathen. The English Wikipedia offers a possible reason, that Christianity was tied to his enemies; that is a conjecture, the sources do not say it.

A second sign of his helpfulness follows in chapters 25 and 26. Ansgar wished to go to Sweden and asked the king, whom Robinson has him call his intimate friend, for support. Horik gave him a message and a token for the Swedish king Olef, saying he had never seen so good a man or found anyone so trustworthy. This too comes from a saint's life that shows the missionary in the best light.

How powerful was Horik?

The question can only be answered indirectly. Much suggests that Horik had a court, followers and access to ships: he could send envoys, raise armies at the Eider and, if the annalists' 600 are even roughly right, equip a large fleet.

Against this stands that his realm was evidently not secure. As Wikipedia notes, kings in the north were chosen at assemblies rather than by fixed succession. Relatives could make claims, and that is what happened. What Horik controlled cannot be mapped. The German Wikipedia says he ruled parts of Denmark and Scania; I have not checked Scania in the sources.

The gap in written evidence also affects administration. There is no charter from Horik, no seal, no coin with his name. That does not mean there was nothing, only that nothing survives. Archaeologically Hedeby is attested as a trading place in the ninth century, as is the Danevirke as a border rampart; which building phases Horik ordered is not known to me. More in the article on the Danevirke.

850 to 854: nephews, partition and end

Around 850, according to the Annals of St-Bertin, Horik shared power with two nephews after hard fighting. The Latin nepotes can also mean "grandsons" or more generally "relatives", as the discussion about Rorik shows; whether nephews are meant is interpretation as well. Wikipedia speaks of a division of the realm into thirds. Why Horik agreed, the annals do not say.

For 852 the Annals of Fulda report that a Harald who had fled Horik's anger was received kindly, baptised and later murdered. Whether this is Harald Klak remains open, according to the article on Harald Klak.

In 854 Guttorm, a nephew whom Horik had driven out, returned and claimed the kingship. According to the English Wikipedia the battle lasted three days; Horik and "the other kings" fell, as did Guttorm and many chiefs. This agrees with Robinson's introduction, where he and nearly all his chiefs are said to have been killed in a three-day battle. A child named Horik, the later Horik II, was left. After 854, according to St-Bertin, Rorik and Godfrid came from Frisia in 855 to demand a share of the realm and were refused.

A correction to the commission: there was no "war with Horik II"; the opponent was a nephew, Guttorm, and Horik II was a child. A fighting year of 853 is not attested in my sources; the fighting is dated to 854.

Afterlife: Eric, Saxo and the silence of the sagas

That Horik hardly appears in Norse tradition is a striking result of the source situation. The Icelandic king lists omit him, according to Wikipedia. Saxo calls him "Eric" and gives him a relation to Harald Klak that the annals do not know. Adam of Bremen, the eleventh-century church historian of Hamburg, knew the period from Rimbert's Vita; he is a topic of his own. The saga hero Ragnar Lodbrok, by contrast, has a large role in the stories of later centuries; those stories have little to do with Horik.

Myth check

  • "Horik destroyed Hamburg in 845." Rimbert reports the attack but names no king. The attribution to Horik comes from later interpretation and is disputed; Lund rejects it.
  • "Horik led 600 ships to Paris." The 600 ships went up the Elbe against Louis, according to St-Bertin. The fleet that reached Paris numbered 120 ships under Reginheri.
  • "Ragnar Lodbrok was Horik's vassal or general." That link comes from later stories. The annals name Reginheri; whether he equals the saga hero remains disputed.
  • "Horik was baptised." Rimbert shows him friendly to Christianity but not baptised. As far as is known he stayed a heathen.
  • "Horik II defeated Horik I in a family war." The opponent was Guttorm, a nephew; Horik II was a surviving child.

Frequently asked questions

Was Horik I a Viking? The word misleads for the ninth century. The sources call him rex, king of the Danes or of the Northmen. He was a ruler on the border of the Frankish Empire, not a saga hero.

Who was Horik II? A child who survived the royal family's fight in 854 and became king afterwards. How he was related to Horik I is not recorded; according to Wikipedia possibly as nephew or grandson.

Did Horik destroy Hamburg? That cannot be established. Rimbert names pirates without a king, Lund denies it, other readings assign it to Ragnar's fleet or to Horik.

Why did Horik allow a church? Rimbert presents it as accommodation to a man the king valued. Diplomacy toward Louis the German may lie behind it; that is interpretation, not a source statement.

Where is all this recorded? In the Annals of St-Bertin, Fulda and Xanten, the Royal Frankish Annals and Rimbert's Vita Anskarii. No Danish sources from his time exist.

Further reading on this site

Godfred · Harald Klak · Ansgar · Hedeby · Paris 845 · Ragnar Lodbrok · Rorik of Dorestad · Dorestad · The Danevirke · Nordic kings

the Ancestral Line – a deity portrait of your choice
From our workshop: the Ancestral Line – a deity portrait of your choice – laser-engraved on natural slate. To the shop →

Read more with us

Godfred · Hedeby · Harald Klak · Rorik of Dorestad · Dorestad – the great trading place.

Sources & literature

Visit the Shop More posts

More from History & Finds

All History & Finds articles →

Housecarls: Cnut's retinue in England, a law from the wrong century and the question of a standing army

For a long time the housecarls passed for England's first professional army: Danish elite warriors brought over by Cnut …

Read more →

Ibn Fadlan: an envoy from Baghdad among the Rus on the Volga

Ibn Fadlan was the secretary of an embassy sent by the Abbasid caliph al-Muqtadir from Baghdad to the Volga Bulgars in …

Read more →

Ibrāhīm ibn Yaʿqūb: What a Traveller from Spain Saw in Hedeby

Around the year 965 a stranger came to the Schlei. He came from Tortosa in al-Andalus, Muslim Spain, was Jewish, a …

Read more →

The Iceni: Boudicca's People between Gold, Coins and Revolt

Few peoples of Iron Age Britain left so many traces and at the same time vanished so completely behind a single person …

Read more →