Viking Blog / Feasts & Customs
The Knowledge Archive

How Did the Germanic Peoples Celebrate Midwinter? Yule on the Continent

Feasts & Customs How Did the Germanic Peoples Celebrate Midwinter? Yule on the Continent

Anyone who tries to find out how Franks, Alemanni, Saxons or Frisians spent the darkest weeks of the year before they were baptised runs into an awkward truth: not a single contemporary account of a Germanic midwinter festival on the European mainland survives. What we have are fragments. A month name in a scrap of Gothic calendar, a line in Tacitus about drinking bouts that ran for days, Charlemagne's "holy month", altar stones to the Mothers in the Rhineland and, above all, the long lists of things the Church wanted stamped out. This article lays those fragments out on the table, tests each one in turn and then builds a reconstruction from them, clearly labelled as such.

The honest answer first: there is no eyewitness

For Scandinavia the situation is comparatively comfortable. Skaldic verse, the sagas and Snorri's histories of the Norwegian kings tell of jól, of Yule ale, of the sacrificial feast at Hlaðir and of King Hákon, who is said to have moved the festival to the date of Christmas. Most of these texts were written down in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, long after the events they describe, but they still give us names, scenes and dates. What can be said about the Scandinavian festival on that basis is covered in our articles on Yule and on Yule in the North.

On the continent things look very different. Between the Rhine and the Elbe, between the North Sea and the Alps, nobody described a pagan midwinter festival while it was still being celebrated. Roman writers cared about warfare and customs, not about festival calendars. Missionaries cared about what had to be abolished, and they named it with Latin terms lifted from the handbooks they had brought with them. By the time people from these peoples began to write for themselves, they were already Christians.

That situation dictates a method. Four kinds of evidence have to be kept firmly apart. First, contemporary written sources about the continental Germanic peoples that touch on winter or the turn of the year. Second, linguistic evidence: words and month names. Third, archaeology, which tells us about houses, farming and cult. Fourth, analogies from neighbouring cultures, namely Anglo-Saxon England, the Christian Frankish kingdom and the pagan North. Only towards the end of this article, and clearly marked, will you find a reconstruction. Everything before it is the evidence itself.

For an overview of the whole Germanic festival year, see our article on Germanic festivals. The focus here is narrower: the middle of winter on the mainland.

Tacitus: winter, beer and feasting without a calendar

The oldest detailed account of the Germanic peoples is the Germania of the Roman historian Publius Cornelius Tacitus, written in AD 98. Tacitus probably never set foot in Germania himself and worked from earlier reports. His book is also a mirror held up to Rome: the Germani often appear as an unspoilt counter-image to Roman decadence. Every sentence has to be read with that in mind.

Tacitus does not mention a midwinter festival. In fact he names no seasonal festival at all. There is the procession of the goddess Nerthus in chapter 40, for which he gives no date, and there are gatherings of the Semnones in a sacred grove "at a fixed time" in chapter 39. What he does describe in striking detail is how people feasted. In chapter 22 he sketches a daily routine in which winter is named outright:

"Statim e somno, quem plerumque in diem extrahunt, lavantur, saepius calida, ut apud quos plurimum hiems occupat. … Tum ad negotia nec minus saepe ad convivia procedunt armati. Diem noctemque continuare potando nulli probrum. … Sed et de reconciliandis in vicem inimicis et iungendis adfinitatibus et adsciscendis principibus, de pace denique ac bello plerumque in conviviis consultant."

"As soon as they wake from sleep, which they usually drag out well into the day, they wash, more often in warm water, as you would expect of people among whom winter takes up the greater part of the year. … Then they go about their business, and just as often to feasts, armed. To drink on through day and night is no disgrace to anyone. … But it is at feasts, too, that they mostly debate the reconciling of enemies, the forging of marriage alliances, the choice of chiefs, and even war and peace."

Tacitus, Germania, ch. 22 (AD 98); Latin text after the Latin Library edition, English translation our own

In the next chapter, 23, Tacitus describes the drink: a liquor made from barley or wheat, "fermented into a certain resemblance to wine". In other words, beer. Those living along the Rhine also bought wine. The food he lists is plain: wild fruit, fresh game, curdled milk. With thirst, Tacitus remarks drily, the Germani are less restrained than with hunger; you could defeat them more easily with drink than with weapons.

The feast, the convivium, is not a private pleasure in Tacitus. It is where alliances are made, marriages arranged and leaders chosen. The Scandinavian Yule feast still had exactly that function a thousand years later: vows were sworn there, retinues confirmed, guests honoured. It is tempting to assume that a midwinter festival on the continent took the form of just such a feast, and the assumption is reasonable. It is not, however, attested. Tacitus is talking about feasting in general, not about any particular date.

Counting by nights: how the Germanic peoples measured time

For midwinter, another sentence in the Germania matters more. In chapter 11 Tacitus writes that assemblies were held on fixed days, "when the moon is either new or full", because this was thought the most auspicious start for any undertaking. He goes on to say that the Germani did not count days, as the Romans did, but nights: the night seems to lead the day.

This report is well supported. English fortnight, "fourteen nights", still bears witness to it, as do medieval legal texts that set deadlines in nights, and Old Norse festival names such as vetrnætr, "winter nights". Bede, writing in the eighth century, also says that the year of the pagan Anglo-Saxons began with a night. For a midwinter festival, that has two consequences. The high point probably fell on the eve and through the night, not on the following day. And the date was probably set by the moon, not by a fixed solar date.

A third sentence, from chapter 26, is often overlooked. The Germani, Tacitus says, did not divide the year into four seasons as the Romans did. Winter, spring and summer they knew as ideas and had words for; of autumn they knew neither the name nor its gifts. He means wine and orchard fruit. The observation fits the later division of the Norse year into a winter half and a summer half. How month names grew out of this lunar rhythm is the subject of our article on Germanic month names.

Just as important is what does not follow from Tacitus. He mentions no solstice, no fires and no gods of winter. Anyone who speaks of "the solstice festival of the ancient Germans" and cites the Germania as their authority has not a single sentence of that text to stand on.

A Gothic leaf from Bobbio: "fruma jiuleis"

The oldest trace of the word that became jól in the North and Yule in English comes not from Scandinavia but from Italy. The Biblioteca Ambrosiana in Milan holds a manuscript that scholars call Codex Ambrosianus A. It is a palimpsest from the monastery of Bobbio: a Gothic copy of the Pauline epistles was scraped off and written over, but the older text can still be read. The manuscript is usually dated to the sixth century, the time of the Ostrogothic kingdom in Italy.

On one of the last leaves there is a short calendar fragment. It lists commemorations for a few weeks in late autumn, among them Gothic martyrs, the emperor Constantine and the apostle Philip. Above one section stands the month name: naubaimbair: fruma jiuleis. The first word is Latin November in Gothic spelling. The second means literally "the earlier Yule" or "before Yule". Wilhelm Streitberg's standard Gothic dictionary (1910) renders it as "the month before the Yule month". Whether the word naubaimbair actually stands in the manuscript at all is, however, disputed; an image analysis by David Landau (2006) has cast doubt on it. The Gothic name fruma jiuleis itself is secure.

What follows from this is remarkable. Among the Gots, who became Christians in the fourth century under Bishop Wulfila, there was a month that lay "before Yule". So there must also have been a Yule month, presumably December. That matches Bede, who names two months called Giuli, one before and one after the winter solstice. The name, then, was common Germanic and reaches back well before the Viking Age. About the festival, though, the fragment says nothing. It is a Christian calendar of saints that happens to keep using an old month name. What the pagan Goths did in their Yule month remains unknown. More on the history of this people can be found in our article on the Goths.

The missing word: no Yule between the Rhine and the Elbe

Gothic jiuleis, Old English geola and giuli, Old Norse jól and ýlir: the word is attested in three branches of the Germanic languages. In Old High German, Old Saxon and Old Frisian, by contrast, it has not been found. No gloss, no month name, no place name on the continent preserves a "Yule". The modern German word Jul, which turns up today in Julfest, Julklapp or Julbock, is a late borrowing from the Scandinavian languages; the Duden dictionary traces it back to Old Norse jól.

This silence allows two readings. Either Franks, Alemanni and Saxons called the festival something else, or the name had already fallen out of use before vernacular writing began around 800. The second reading gains some support from the fact that the word appears in Gothic and Old English, which makes it a shared inheritance. There is no way to decide between the two.

What replaced it, on the other hand, is well documented: the German word Weihnachten, "Christmas". According to current research, its earliest attestation is in a collection of sermons, the Speculum ecclesiae, from around 1170, in the forms diu wîhe naht and ze den wîhen nahten. Around 1190 the poet Spervogel uses it too. Wîh means "holy, consecrated". The form wîhen nahten is a dative plural, "at the holy nights". Whether several festival nights were meant has not been settled. Either way, Weihnachten is not a pagan word. It is a Christian coinage that appears more than a thousand years after Tacitus.

Bede as a witness from next door: what reaches across the North Sea

The single most important source for a West Germanic midwinter festival is an Anglo-Saxon monk. In his treatise on time-reckoning, De temporum ratione, written in 725, Bede the Venerable describes in chapter 15 the months of his pagan forebears. The Anglo-Saxons had come to Britain from the continental homelands of the Angles, Saxons and Jutes, in the fifth century and afterwards. Their calendar is therefore the closest comparison we have for northern Germany and Jutland.

Bede reports that the months called Giuli took their name "from the turning of the sun towards the increase of the day", one preceding it and the other following. The year began on 25 December, and the night before it the heathens called Modranecht, "the night of the mothers". November he calls Blodmonath, the "month of sacrifice", because in it the cattle that were to be slaughtered were dedicated to the gods. All of this is discussed at length in our article on the Rauhnächte and Modranecht; what matters here is what it means for the continent.

It means three things. First, Bede shows that a West Germanic people understood midwinter as the boundary of the year and gave it a name. Second, he ties this boundary to a special night and to female figures in the plural. Third, he puts the great slaughter in the month before Yule. How much of this was brought over from the mainland, Bede does not say; he was writing almost three hundred years after the crossing. Transferring his information to Saxons on the Weser or Franks on the Rhine is an argument by analogy. A good one, but not proof.

Charlemagne's "holy month": month names from the Frankish kingdom

The only continental source that gives a vernacular name for December is Einhard's Life of Charlemagne, written in the years after the emperor's death in 814. In chapter 29 Einhard reports that Charles gave the months names in his own language, "whereas before that they had been called among the Franks partly by Latin, partly by barbarian names". January he called wintarmanoth, February hornung, November herbistmanoth and December heilagmanoth, "holy month".

The same chapter says that Charles had the "barbarous and very ancient songs in which the deeds and wars of the kings of old were sung" written down. That collection is lost. But the chapter shows a ruler who deliberately reached back to the vernacular, and that is the backdrop against which heilagmanoth has to be read.

Where does the "holy" come from? The simplest explanation is Christian. Christmas falls in December, and in the year 800 Charles had been crowned emperor in Rome on 25 December, of all days. A pre-Christian background is possible but cannot be demonstrated. It is at least worth noting that Einhard explicitly mentions older "barbarian" names already in circulation among the Franks. Whether heilagmanoth was one of them or a new coinage, he does not tell us. It is also worth noting that Charles did not use "Yule" and simply called November the autumn month. Anyone who cites heilagmanoth as proof of a pagan "holy Yule festival" is reading more into the text than it contains. The meaning of the other names is explained in our article on month names.

The Mothers on the Rhine: matron stones and the question of a Mothers' Night

For the Rhineland there is a body of evidence that no other part of the Germanic mainland offers in such density: the matron stones. More than a thousand votive stones to the Matronae or Matres are known from across the Roman Empire, and the heaviest concentration lies in the province of Germania Inferior, between Cologne, Bonn, the Eifel and the Jülich area. The Jülich area is less than half an hour's drive from our workshop in Alsdorf, where we laser-engrave Norse motifs. Most of the stones date from the second and third centuries. They usually show three seated women and carry epithets such as Aufaniae or Vacallinehae, many of which are interpreted as Germanic; the sanctuary at Pesch near Nettersheim was still being extended in the fourth century. Our article on the Matronae covers them in detail.

What this establishes is that a widespread cult of collective mother goddesses existed in the Rhineland, and that Germanic-speaking people took part in it. Everything beyond that is uncertain. Not one matron stone names a festival date. We do not know whether offerings were made to the Mothers in winter, at harvest or on any day at all. The link to Bede's Modranecht is a hypothesis that rests mainly on the word "mothers" and on the plural. Rudolf Simek, for one, considers a connection between the matron cult, Modranecht and the Norse dísir conceivable. But between the last Rhineland matron stones and Bede's account lie some four hundred years and the North Sea.

Kalends, not Yule: what the Church banned at the start of the year

The richest group of sources on the turn of the year consists of sermons, council decrees and penitentials. They are concrete, with masks, noise, laid tables and gifts, but almost everything they forbid belongs to a Roman festival.

That festival is the Kalendae Ianuariae, the Kalends of January, which is to say 1 January. From 153 BC onwards the Roman consuls took office on that day, and under the empire it grew into a New Year festival lasting several days, with processions, disguises, banquets and good-luck gifts called strenae (hence French étrennes). It was celebrated throughout the empire and outlived Christianisation by centuries. The Church fought it stubbornly, not least because it coincided with the octave of Christmas.

The most important early witness in the West is Caesarius, bishop of Arles in Provence from 502 to 542. In his New Year sermons he rails against people who turn themselves into animals at the Kalends: they "make the little stag" (cervulum facere), pull on hides or put on antlers, while others dress up as an old woman (vetula). According to the secondary literature, he also condemns people who set out tables loaded with food on New Year's night in the belief that this will bring plenty for the whole year; we have not checked the wording of that passage ourselves. The customs he describes are Gallo-Roman.

The councils of the Frankish kingdom ban much the same. A synod at Auxerre, usually dated to 585 or a few years earlier, forbids in its very first canon making the vetula or the cervulus at the January Kalends, or observing "devilish New Year gifts". Around 572, Bishop Martin of Braga wrote a sermon "On the Correction of Peasants" for the rural population of the Suebian kingdom in Galicia. In chapter 16 he denounces, among other things, observing the Kalends, decorating tables and laying out laurel (Kalendas observare, mensas ornare, et lauros ponere). In the eighth century Pirmin, the founder of Reichenau abbey, took over phrases of this kind in his Scarapsus. The Suebi were a Germanic people, but the list itself comes from the ancient tradition of Christian preaching.

The Council of Tours in 567 finally set out an arrangement whose effects are still felt today. The days from Christmas to Epiphany were declared a festive season in which nobody should fast. The first three days of January, by contrast, were to be days of penance, so that the faithful would not slip into the customs of the Kalends. Here lies one of the roots of the Twelve Days, the "time between the years" as German still calls it. It is a creation of the Christian calendar and of its rivalry with the Roman New Year. That Germanic ideas later gathered around this period is possible, but it is a later development, traced in our article on the Rauhnächte and Modranecht.

It is very tempting to read all these disguises, tables and noisy processions as "Germanic Yule custom", and Jacob Grimm often did exactly that in his Deutsche Mythologie. Scholarship today is more sober. The bans almost always hang on the Roman date of the Kalends, whereas a Germanic festival was most likely set by the moon. The texts also copy from one another: a ban formulated in sixth-century Arles reappears in penitentials of the eighth and ninth centuries, and nobody can say whether the custom was really practised in Bavaria or on the Lower Rhine. And a writer who says "Diana" or "the Parcae" may be describing a local belief, but he is doing so in Roman vocabulary. None of this makes the bans worthless. They show that across the Frankish kingdom the turn of the year was a time for feasting, for dressing up and for trying to see into the coming year. But they only prove a custom where a witness describes, in his own words, what he has seen with his own eyes. Boniface is such a witness.

Boniface's complaint: Alemanni, Bavarians and Franks in Rome

In 742 the Anglo-Saxon missionary Boniface, who had been working for decades among Hessians, Thuringians and Bavarians, wrote to the newly elected Pope Zacharias. The letter, number 50 in Michael Tangl's edition, contains a complaint that is revealing for our subject precisely because it is not about Germania. It is about Rome.

The "carnal and ignorant" Alemanni, Bavarians and Franks, Boniface writes in substance, see on their pilgrimages to Rome that at the beginning of January, near St Peter's, processions go on day and night. People parade through the streets in the pagan manner with shouting and singing, keep tables laden with food and drink from morning to evening, and during these days nobody will lend a neighbour fire or tools out of their own house. Women wear pagan amulets and bands on their arms and legs and offer them for sale. When the Germans see all this in Rome, they assume it is permitted.

The letter is valuable because it is dated and reports observations. It shows that the New Year customs of the Kalends were still alive in eighth-century Rome itself. And it shows that Boniface thought them contagious: the Germans were precisely not supposed to adopt them. That is a strong argument that these customs were Roman rather than Germanic. The ban on giving fire out of the house during these days does, however, resurface in later German folklore, a good example of how Roman New Year custom could put down roots north of the Alps.

What the Indiculus leaves out

If any text ought to name a Germanic midwinter festival, it is this one. The Indiculus superstitionum et paganiarum, the "little index of superstitions and pagan practices", is a list of thirty chapter headings preserved in a single manuscript in the Vatican Library (Codex Palatinus latinus 577). It was compiled in the second half of the eighth century in the circle of the Frankish mission, probably with Saxony or Hesse in mind. Whether it is connected with Boniface and the synods of the 740s or belongs to the time of Charlemagne is disputed. Only the headings survive; the texts that went with them are lost.

The list names offerings at graves; songs for the dead, which it calls by the vernacular word dadsisas; sacred groves under the puzzling name nimidas; offerings at stones and springs; festivals for "Jupiter or Mercury", which most likely means Donar and Wodan; need-fire kindled by rubbing wood (nodfyr); a "pagan run" called yrias, with torn clothes and shoes; and images of gods made of dough, of cloth, and one "that is carried through the fields". In third place stand the spurcalia in Februario, "unclean practices in February".

A midwinter festival is not on the list, and neither are the January Kalends. That may mean such a festival played no great role in the mission field, or that Christmas had already replaced it, or simply that chance has shaped what survived. Either way, it is a warning against treating Yule as the self-evident centre of continental paganism. The only month the list mentions is February, not December.

Burchard's New Year questions: rooftop, bull's hide and bread

Between about 1008 and 1012 Burchard, bishop of Worms, compiled a large collection of church law, the Decretum. Its nineteenth book, the Corrector ("the corrector"), is a confessor's manual: a long list of questions the priest is to put to penitents. Many are copied from older texts. A few concern the turn of the year.

Have you, Burchard asks, kept the January Kalends "according to the custom of the pagans"? Have you sat on the roof of your house that night, girded with your sword, in order to see and learn what would befall you in the coming year? Have you sat on a bull's hide at a crossroads to discover the future? Have you had loaves baked in your name that night, so as to read the luck of the coming year from how well they rose? Elsewhere he forbids spinning, weaving or sewing on the holy night of the Christmas octave, that is, going into 1 January. The same prohibition returns in later folklore of the Twelve Days as the ban on spinning.

One further question is famous. Have you, at certain times of the year, laid a table in your house with food, drink and three knives for the three sisters whom the people call the Parcae, so that they might allot you good things? This question is often quoted as a New Year custom, yet the wording names no fixed date; it speaks only of "certain times of the year". It recalls Bede's "mothers" and the Matronae, but the figures it names are the Roman goddesses of fate. More on Burchard's catalogue of questions, including the earliest mention of Holda, can be found in our article on Frau Holle.

Burchard's questions are the most colourful source on the turn of the year in the German-speaking area. But they mix borrowed material with his own, and they show the popular religion of an episcopal city that had been Christian for centuries, around the year 1000. They do not show the paganism of the fifth century.

Christmas crosses the Alps: from Rome to Reims

While the Germanic peoples of the mainland were still pagan, a Christian feast on 25 December had already taken hold in Rome. The oldest evidence comes from a luxury calendar made for a wealthy Roman, the so-called Chronograph of 354. In a list of commemorations that goes back to models from the year 336, the entry for 25 December reads: "Christ born in Bethlehem of Judaea". In the same calendar, that day is also marked as the birthday of the "Unconquered", the sun god Sol Invictus.

Why this day of all days? Scholars have argued about it since the nineteenth century. The history-of-religions thesis, championed among others by Hermann Usener, sees Christmas as a Christian answer to the feast of the sun god. The calculation thesis, put forward by Louis Duchesne, points to early Christian computations that placed both the conception and the death of Jesus on the same day, 25 March; nine months later comes 25 December. Both theses still have their defenders. For our subject only one thing matters: the date has nothing to do with a Germanic Yule. It was fixed long before missionaries appeared north of the Alps.

The feast reached the Frankish kingdom through the Gallo-Roman Church. The Frankish king Clovis was baptised by Bishop Remigius in Reims, and the baptism took place at Christmas; the year is disputed, with proposals ranging from 496 to 508. Bishop Avitus of Vienne sent him a letter of congratulation. From the very beginning, then, Christmas was a royal feast for the Frankish elite. Three centuries later Charlemagne had himself crowned emperor in St Peter's on 25 December 800. In many parts of the empire the new year was counted from Christmas until the sixteenth century, a convention known as the Christmas style of dating. How the Franks and Alemanni as a whole came to Christianity is described in our article on the Christianisation of the Germanic peoples.

Saxony: mission by the sword, Christmas in the Heliand

The longest holdouts of paganism on the mainland were the Saxons between the Rhine, the Weser and the Elbe. From 772 to 804 Charlemagne waged war on them. In his very first campaign he destroyed the sanctuary of the Irminsul, and he forced those he subdued to accept baptism. According to the Royal Frankish Annals he spent Christmas 784 in the middle of the war zone, in camp on the river Emmer near Lügde (villa Liuhidi). To the Saxons, the feast of Christ's birth must at first have been the feast of their conquerors.

A law for the conquered territory, the Capitulatio de partibus Saxoniae (usually dated to around 782–785, though the details are disputed), made cremation and the continuation of pagan customs capital offences. One article sets penalties for anyone who makes a vow at springs, trees or groves, offers anything in the manner of the pagans "and eats in honour of the demons". This is one of the very few continental pieces of evidence for the sacrificial meal: animals were offered and eaten together, and the shared meal was part of the cult. The text names no date.

A generation after the war, around 830, the Heliand was composed in Old Saxon, a retelling of the Gospels in some six thousand alliterative long lines. Christ appears in it as a lord with his retinue, the disciples as his thanes, and the Christmas story is transformed as well. In Luke, shepherds keep watch over their sheep; in the Heliand they are watchmen standing outside at night with the horses. Karl Simrock's German rendering of 1856 says that the news came first to "watchmen who were out in the open with the horses, herding shepherds who stayed with the steeds and with the cattle in the field". This is no report of a pagan festival. It does show how, in the ninth century, people translated the birth of Christ into a world of horse-breeding, retinues and winter nights: the world in which the pagan midwinter festival must previously have had its place.

Sacrificial meal and feast: what analogies can do and where they stop

Every reconstruction leans on the neighbours. Three comparisons are especially important, and all three have limits.

The first is a letter Pope Gregory the Great wrote in 601 to Abbot Mellitus, who was setting out for the Anglo-Saxon mission. Bede preserves it in his Ecclesiastical History (Book I, chapter 30). The English, Gregory writes, are accustomed to sacrificing many oxen to demons. This should not simply be forbidden; instead, on the anniversaries of church dedications and the feasts of martyrs, they should be allowed to build huts of branches around the churches and to slaughter and eat the animals in praise of God. That is clear evidence of a West Germanic sacrificial meal involving cattle, and of a mission strategy that repurposed such feasts. It names no winter date.

The second is Norse Yule, especially Snorri's account of the sacrificial feast at Hlaðir in his saga of Hákon the Good: blood of the sacrificial animals, meat from cauldrons over fires in the middle of the hall, cups drained to Odin, Njörðr and Freyr. Snorri was writing around 1230 about the tenth century and had no first-hand knowledge of paganism. For the continent of the fifth to eighth centuries, that is a comparison across great distances in both space and time.

The third is Thietmar of Merseburg's account of a sacrificial festival held in January at Lejre on Zealand, examined in our article on Yule in the North. For the continent it proves nothing.

Taken together, these analogies form a pattern. In the Germanic world, a great festival meant slaughtering, eating the sacrificial meat together and drinking with religious meaning. That such a festival existed on the continent at midwinter is likely, because the word, the month name and the analogies all point that way. What it looked like in detail has not come down to us.

Slaughter time, beer and stores: the economics of winter

Archaeology offers firmer ground, even though it does not dig up festivals, only houses, byres and rubbish. The best-studied site is Feddersen Wierde, a dwelling mound (Wurt) in the Land Wursten between Wremen and Mulsum, near the mouth of the Weser. Between 1954 and 1963 it was excavated almost completely under Werner Haarnagel. People lived there for about six hundred years, from the first century BC into the fifth century AD; at its peak in the third century the settlement had 26 longhouses with roughly 300 inhabitants.

The longhouse, with people and animals under one roof, is the key to the Germanic winter. A large byre and a smaller living area with a hearth shared the building, which at Feddersen Wierde measured about 20 by 5 metres. In winter the cattle stood in the byre. How many animals could be brought through the winter depended on how much hay had been gathered. That produces a rhythm that can be inferred even without written sources: in late autumn the animals that could not be fed through to spring were slaughtered. Bede explicitly calls November the "month of sacrifice", so at least among the Anglo-Saxons the slaughter had a religious frame. Afterwards there was fresh meat in abundance for a few weeks.

Beer is tied to the same rhythm. The grain was in, and work in the fields had stopped. A midwinter festival at which fresh beer and the meat of the autumn slaughter were consumed together would have made good economic sense. That is plausible, but it remains an inference. For more on the role of beer at feasts, see our article on beer in the Viking Age.

Feddersen Wierde also produced a large farmstead with outbuildings, which the excavators interpret as a "chieftain's farm", and a large building with no internal divisions that may have served as a meeting hall. Whether anyone feasted in it, the evidence does not say. It does show a place where more people could gather than in an ordinary dwelling. The excavation at Flögeln in the district of Cuxhaven produced a similar picture of settlement.

An evening at midwinter: a labelled reconstruction

What follows is a reconstruction, not an account from the sources. It assembles the attested building blocks for a village on the North Sea coast in the third or fourth century, and every detail names its basis.

The date: not a fixed calendar day but a night around midwinter, probably set by a new or full moon (Tacitus, ch. 11; the Gothic "Yule month"; Bede's two Yule months around the solstice). The festival began in the evening and was reckoned in nights. Whether it lasted one, three or more nights is unknown; the three-day length given in Norse sources cannot simply be carried over.

The preparations: the slaughter lay weeks in the past, in the "month of sacrifice" (Bede). Meat had been salted and smoked, and little was left fresh. Beer had been brewed from barley (Tacitus, ch. 23). If an animal was set aside for sacrifice at the festival itself, it was probably an ox or a pig; this is not attested for winter on the continent, only the sacrificial meal in general (Capitulatio, Gregory's letter).

The place: the largest house in the village, or a meeting building like the one at Feddersen Wierde (archaeology). Guests came armed (Tacitus, ch. 22). People ate, drank and deliberated about feuds, marriages and leaders (Tacitus, ch. 22). Whether gods were invoked, and which, we do not know. The inscriptions from the Rhine show that mother goddesses were worshipped; that offerings were made to them on this night is a hypothesis (matron stones, Bede).

What there was not, as far as we know: no decorated tree, no presents under a tree, no fire as a symbol of the sun, no song to the returning sun. None of these elements has any evidence before the High Middle Ages.

This reconstruction is thin, and that is the honest outcome: far sparer than most of the accounts you will be offered during Advent.

Masks, noise and the Twelve Days: what came later

Much of what passes today for "ancient Yule custom" is attested on the continent only in the late Middle Ages or the early modern period. Perchten processions in the Alps become tangible as a custom mainly from the sixteenth century onwards, and the Rauhnächte as a fixed season of smudging and divination are likewise described in detail only in the early modern period. The idea of the Wild Hunt during the Twelve Nights, in its familiar form, is a construction built from medieval tales of wonders and the legend collections of the nineteenth century.

Between these late customs and the early bans there are similarities: animal disguise, laid tables, bans on work, divination. Yet the evidence on either side is often separated by more than half a millennium. And where a line of descent can be traced, it leads more often to the Roman Kalends than to a Germanic Yule. How today's festival was assembled from these layers is the subject of our article on Christmas customs and their Nordic roots; remembrance of the dead at this time of year is covered in the one on ancestor veneration at Yule.

What is secure

  • No contemporary account of a midwinter festival exists for the continental Germanic peoples.
  • Tacitus (AD 98) attests feasts with beer at which alliances, marriages and questions of leadership were debated, as well as a reckoning of time by nights and phases of the moon, but no festival calendar.
  • The Gothic month name fruma jiuleis ("before Yule") in a sixth-century calendar fragment shows that the word Yule was a common Germanic inheritance.
  • Bede (725) names two Yule months for the Anglo-Saxons, a year beginning on 25 December, Modranecht and a November "month of sacrifice".
  • Einhard records heilagmanoth ("holy month") as Charlemagne's name for December; whether the name is pre-Christian remains open.
  • From the first to the fourth century there was a pronounced cult of the Matronae in the Rhineland; no festival date has come down to us.
  • Most of the Church's New Year bans (Caesarius, Auxerre, Boniface, Burchard) target customs of the Roman January Kalends.
  • Christmas on 25 December is attested in Rome by 336 at the latest and has no Germanic origin; the German word Weihnachten is not attested until around 1170.

Yule trees, solstice fires, Frau Holle: common misconceptions

Myth check

  • "The Germanic peoples decorated a tree for Yule." There is not a single piece of evidence for this from the Germanic period. The earliest reports of decorated Christmas trees date from the sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries and come from the Upper Rhine and Alsace, from an urban, Christian setting. That Boniface felled an oak at Geismar in 723 is evidence of a tree sacred to Donar, not of a festive tree at midwinter; more on this in our article on Donar's Oak.
  • "At Yule the Germanic peoples lit solstice fires." No source from the Germanic period mentions a fire at the winter solstice. The fires in the Indiculus (nodfyr) are need-fires with no date attached. The well-known annual fires are the midsummer fires of St John's Day and the Easter and Shrovetide fires in spring, all attested in Christian times. What can actually be said about the solstice is set out in our article on the solstice.
  • "Frau Holle was the Germanic goddess of Yule." The name Holda first appears around 1010 in Burchard of Worms, as the leader of women who ride out at night, with no winter date. Her connection with the Twelve Nights is attested only later, and her elevation to "goddess" goes back largely to Jacob Grimm. A Holda in the paganism of the fifth century cannot be demonstrated.
  • "Christmas was placed on the date of Yule to win over the Germanic peoples." The date of 25 December had been fixed in Rome before there was any significant mission among the Germanic peoples. That the Church later reinterpreted pagan festivals is shown by Gregory's letter of 601, but that letter concerns church dedications and martyrs' feasts, not Christmas.

Frequently asked questions

Did the continental Germanic peoples have a Yule festival at all? There was probably a festival at midwinter, since the word Yule is attested among the Goths, the Anglo-Saxons and the Scandinavians, and Bede describes a beginning of the year with a special night for the Anglo-Saxons. For the Franks, Alemanni or Saxons, neither the name nor a description has survived.

When was the festival celebrated? Probably on a night around midwinter, set by the moon. A fixed date such as 21 or 25 December is not attested for the pagan period on the continent.

What did people eat and drink? No menu has survived. Beer and meat from the autumn slaughter are a reasoned guess, supported by Tacitus and by the attested sacrificial meal.

Is Modranecht proof of a Germanic festival of the Mothers in the Rhineland? No. Bede describes it in 725 for the Anglo-Saxons, and the Rhineland matron stones give no date. A connection is a hypothesis worth taking seriously, nothing more.

Are New Year divination customs Germanic in origin? The earliest bans concern the Roman Kalends of January. Around 1010 Burchard of Worms mentions divination on the rooftop, on a bull's hide and by baking bread. Whether Germanic ideas lie behind any of these cannot be decided case by case.

Further reading on this site

Yule: the word, the sources and the history of the festival · Yule in the North · Germanic festivals through the year · Germanic month names · The Rauhnächte and Modranecht · The Matronae of the Rhineland · The Saxons · The Christianisation of the Germanic peoples · The Goths · Frau Holle · The solstice · Christmas customs and their Nordic roots

tealight holder God Jul with Yule goat
From our workshop: tealight holder “God Jul” with Yule goat – laser-engraved on crystal glass. To the shop →

Read more with us

The Germanic feasts · Forgotten Germanic month names · The Rauhnächte & Mother's Night · How a Yule Feast Unfolded in the North – a Reconstruction from Sagas, Laws and Archaeology · The Christianisation of the Germanic Peoples.

Sources & literature

Visit the Shop More posts

More from Festivals & Belief

All Festivals & Belief articles →

How a Yule Feast Unfolded in the North – a Reconstruction from Sagas, Laws and Archaeology

No Viking ever wrote down how his Yule feast went. What survives are fragments: a praise poem from around 900, a Saxon …

Read more →

The Four Celtic Festivals – Samhain, Imbolc, Beltane and Lughnasadh Between Evidence and the Wheel

Four festivals structure the "Celtic year": Samhain, Imbolc, Beltane and Lughnasadh. Almost everything we know about …

Read more →

Celtic Religion – Druids, Gods and Sacred Places Between Evidence and Legend

The Celts did not write their faith down. What we know comes from Caesar, Strabo, Pliny and Tacitus, from votive stones …

Read more →

Places of Power in the North and Germania - sacred sites between evidence and myth

Few terms are as popular and as misunderstood as the "place of power". People make pilgrimages to stone circles …

Read more →