Hardly a December goes by without someone claiming that the Christmas tree is really Yggdrasil, that kissing under the mistletoe was a gift from the goddess Frigg, and that Christmas is just Yule with a new name. Some of this has a genuine core. A good deal of it was invented in the nineteenth or twentieth century. We take the familiar customs one at a time and ask the same questions every time: what is being claimed, where is the earliest evidence, where does the custom most likely come from, and what is left standing at the end?
Anyone who wants to know whether a custom goes back to the Viking Age, or even further, needs a yardstick. The obvious test, "does it sound vaguely pagan?", is useless. Almost anything that involves fire, evergreens, light and food in midwinter sounds ancient to modern ears. What matters is when and where a custom first becomes visible in writing or in the ground, and whether an unbroken line can be traced from there to the present.
For this article we therefore separate five layers. The first is archaeology: objects, sacrificial sites, food remains. The second is contemporary writing, meaning texts produced during the period itself, such as the skaldic poetry of the ninth and tenth centuries. The third is later medieval tradition, above all the Icelandic texts of the thirteenth century such as Snorri Sturluson's Edda or the kings' sagas collected in Heimskringla. The fourth layer is the folklore scholarship of the eighteenth to twentieth centuries, which often recorded customs for the very first time and was quick to supply them with a pagan pedigree in the same breath. The fifth is modern interpretation, all the way down to advertising and social media.
Every section follows the same pattern: the claim, the earliest evidence, the likely origin and a verdict. The verdict comes in four grades. "Attested Nordic" means a source from the pre-Christian or early Christian North describes something that clearly corresponds to the modern custom. "Possible" means there are points of contact, but the line has gaps. "Unattested" means a Nordic origin is asserted without any source to carry it. "Later" means the custom demonstrably arose in the modern era, often at a known place and a known time.
The claim: Because Scandinavians still call Christmas "jul", the whole festival must be Nordic and pagan.
Earliest evidence: The word really is old. In the Gothic calendar fragment of the sixth century, November is called fruma jiuleis, "the month before Yule". The Anglo-Saxon scholar Bede, in his work on time-reckoning (De temporum ratione, chapter 15, written in 725), gives the months of December and January the name Giuli. In the North, a skaldic poem from around 900, the Haraldskvæði, says the king wants to "drink Yule outdoors" (úti vill jól drekka). The word travelled into Finnish as the loanword joulu and into Estonian as jõulud.
Likely origin: There was a Germanic midwinter festival, or at least a midwinter season, that went by this name. What exactly people celebrated, the early sources hardly reveal. The etymology is disputed. We cover the word, Bede and the early attestations in detail in Yule: the Germanic midwinter festival and in the series articles Yule among the Germanic peoples and Yule in the North.
Verdict: The word is attested as Nordic and Germanic. But a word is not a custom. "Yule" survived in English just as "jul" did in Scandinavia, and yet hardly any English Christmas custom can be shown to date from pagan times. The word tells us something about the date, not about how the day was kept.
The claim: The Church took over the Germanic Yule, or the Roman festival of the sun, and painted it over in Christian colours.
Earliest evidence: For 25 December as the feast of Christ's birth in Rome, the key witness is the so-called Chronograph of 354. This compilation contains a list of commemorations (Depositio martyrum) that opens with the entry for 25 December: Christ was born on this day in Bethlehem of Judea. Since the list is widely thought to go back to an exemplar from 336, that year counts as the earliest secure date for the Roman Christmas. The same codex also contains a calendar that marks 25 December as N(atalis) Invicti, the "birthday of the Unconquered", meaning the sun god Sol.
Likely origin: This is where a real scholarly debate begins. The older, popular thesis says Christians deliberately placed their feast on the day of Sol Invictus in order to push it aside. Against it stands the so-called calculation hypothesis, which goes back to Louis Duchesne (1889) and was later developed above all by Thomas Talley. Christian writers, the argument runs, placed the death of Jesus on 25 March and his conception on the same day; count nine months on and you arrive at 25 December. Whether the sun festival on 25 December was even older than the Christian feast is itself contested; the Dutch ancient historian Steven Hijmans has cast doubt on it. All that is certain is that by the middle of the fourth century both feasts stand in the same Roman calendar.
None of this has anything to do with the North at first. Rome was celebrating Christmas centuries before the first church stood in Scandinavia. When Christianity reached Norway, Denmark and Sweden in the tenth and eleventh centuries, a long-established church feast met a native midwinter season. The saga of Hákon the Good in Snorri's Heimskringla, written in the thirteenth century, says that the Christian-raised king made it law that Yule should be held at the same time as the Christians held it; before that, the feast had begun on hǫkunótt, at midwinter. This is a tradition recorded some 270 years after the fact, but it shows the pattern. Rome did not adopt Yule. In the North, the word Yule migrated onto the Christian feast.
Verdict: False as a blanket statement. The date of 25 December is Roman and Christian, not Nordic. What is true is that in the North the old name passed to the new feast, and that some elements, above all communal drinking, lived on. The following sections show which ones.
The claim: Scandinavian Christmas beer is a direct descendant of the pagan sacrificial ale.
Earliest evidence: Here the claim stands on firm ground. The phrase "drink Yule" in the Haraldskvæði of around 900 already assumes that the festival was kept above all by a drinking feast. Hákon's saga in Heimskringla says the king decreed that every man should have a set measure of ale at Yule or pay a fine, and should keep the feast holy for as long as the ale lasted. The Norwegian provincial laws are more concrete still. The older Gulathing Law of western Norway, whose Christian section is rooted in provisions of the eleventh and twelfth centuries, obliges farmers to brew ale for Christmas and to consecrate it to Christ and the Virgin Mary "for a good year and peace", til árs ok friðar. Anyone who failed to brew had to pay a fine; according to common accounts of the law, a man who neglected it three years running forfeited his property.
The formula til árs ok friðar is the truly interesting detail. It turns up in Snorri's description of pagan sacrificial feasts, where people drank til árs ok friðar in honour of the gods. Church law, in other words, did not ban the ale. It kept the act of drinking and replaced the recipient: the toast that had gone to Odin, Njord and Freyr now went to Christ and Mary. This is one of the rare cases where you can almost watch a reinterpretation happen inside a legal text. More on the brewing of the period is in Beer and brewing among the Vikings, and on honey wine in our article on mead.
Likely origin: The communal midwinter feast is pre-Christian and well attested in the North. The juleøl sold by Norwegian breweries today, however, is an industrial product that draws on this tradition. Norwegian folklore records describe brewing on the farms before Christmas as a fixed date in the calendar well into the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, with a first tasting around St Thomas's Day on 21 December.
And Swedish julmust? It is the very opposite of an ancient tradition: a non-alcoholic soft drink made with malt and hops, developed by the businessman Harry Roberts. The Roberts company was founded in Örebro in 1910, and the drink was conceived as an alcohol-free alternative. Its December success in Sweden is a twentieth-century story.
Verdict: Christmas ale in the North: attested Nordic in substance, with a visible Christian rededication. Today's branded juleøl: later, but a genuine continuation. Julmust: later (twentieth century).
The claim: The Swedish julskinka, the Christmas ham of northern Germany and the boar's head of the English feast all go back to the boar sacrificed to the god Freyr, whose golden-bristled boar was called Gullinbursti.
Earliest evidence: There really are Old Norse texts that link a boar with Yule Eve. The prose of the Eddic Helgakviða Hjǫrvarðssonar tells how, on Yule Eve, the sónargǫltr is led in, a special boar of sacrifice or atonement. The men lay their hands on the animal and swear solemn vows over the king's toast, the bragarfull. Heðinn vows that he will win Sváva, the beloved of his brother Helgi, and regrets the oath the moment he has spoken it. The Hervarar saga has a similar scene: King Heiðrekr has a great boar raised, which is led into the hall on Yule Eve so that the men can swear their oaths on its bristles; in one version of the saga the animal is dedicated to Freyr. Both texts survive in manuscripts of the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries and tell of a legendary distant past. The word sónargǫltr itself is difficult. It is usually rendered as "atonement boar" or "leading boar of the herd", but neither reading is secure.
Gullinbursti, for his part, comes from Snorri's Skáldskaparmál: dwarves forge for Freyr a boar with golden bristles that runs through air and water faster than any horse. Christmas or Yule is never mentioned. For boar images on helmets and in graves, see The boar in the North.
For England, the best-known evidence is the Boar's Head Carol. The song about the boar's head carried to table "with bays and rosemary" survives in fifteenth-century versions; Wynkyn de Worde printed a version in 1521 in his Christmasse Carolles.
Likely origin: In the farming year, pigs were slaughtered in late autumn and early winter, because fodder was running short and the cold kept the meat. A pork roast at midwinter follows almost automatically, in Scandinavia just as in England, Poland or Bavaria. Swedish accounts date the modern Christmas ham as the fixed centrepiece of the meal to no earlier than the mid-nineteenth century, first on manor farms and then among the peasantry; before that, pork came to the table salted and in other forms. The link between Freyr's boar and the ham was already drawn by Jacob Grimm in his Deutsche Mythologie and has been repeated ever since. It is a hypothesis. There is a boar at Yule in myth and a ham at Christmas in the nineteenth century, but no intermediate link connects the two.
Verdict: Boar and vows at Yule in Old Norse literature: attested (as thirteenth-century literary tradition about the distant past). The Christmas ham as a descendant of the sacrifice to Freyr: possible, but unattested; the economic explanation is entirely sufficient. The English boar's head: late medieval, with no traceable Nordic line.
The claim: Mistletoe was sacred in the North because it plays a part in the myth of Baldr, and that is why it belongs among the Christmas decorations.
Earliest evidence: The fullest version is in Snorri's Gylfaginning, chapter 49, written around 1220 to 1230. Baldr has bad dreams. His mother Frigg then takes an oath from all things, fire, water, iron, stones, trees, diseases, animals and poisons, that they will not harm him. The gods make a game of shooting and throwing at the invulnerable god. Loki is irritated by this. He disguises himself as a woman, visits Frigg and asks whether really all things have sworn. What follows reads like this in Karl Simrock's German translation of 1851, which we quote because it is the version we read in full for this passage:
„Oestlich von Walhall wächst eine Staude, Mistiltein genannt, die schien mir zu jung, sie in Eid zu nehmen. Darauf ging die Frau fort; Loki nahm den Mistiltein, riß ihn aus und ging zur Versammlung. […] Hödur nahm den Mistelzweig und schoß nach Baldur nach Lokis Anweisung. Der Schuß flog und durchbohrte ihn, daß er todt zur Erde fiel, und das war das gröste Unglück, das Menschen und Götter betraf.“
"East of Valhalla grows a shrub called Mistiltein; it seemed to me too young to take an oath from. Then the woman went away; Loki took the Mistiltein, tore it up and went to the assembly. […] Hödur took the mistletoe sprig and shot at Baldur as Loki directed. The shot flew and pierced him, so that he fell dead to the ground, and that was the greatest misfortune that ever befell gods and men."
Snorri Sturluson, Gylfaginning 49, in Karl Simrock's German translation (Die Edda, 1851; text after the Project Gutenberg edition); English rendering of Simrock's German by the editors
Two things stand out. First, Simrock writes "east", whereas English translations render the same passage as "west of Valhalla", so the compass point already wobbles between transmission and translation. Second, the mistletoe in this story is not a sacred plant at all. It is the overlooked exception, the thing that looks harmless, and that is exactly why it becomes a weapon. That a sprig of mistletoe could pierce a god puzzled nineteenth-century scholars, because mistletoe is a soft semi-parasite and yields no wood fit for a spear. A widespread suggestion is that Snorri took a poetic word, mistilteinn, literally, when it may originally have been a name for a sword as well; and in fact a sword called Mistilteinn appears in later sagas. Other versions of the Baldr material, such as the Danish account by Saxo Grammaticus from around 1200, manage without mistletoe entirely: there Høtherus kills Balderus with a sword.
Likely origin: Mistletoe is firmly part of the thirteenth-century Icelandic Baldr myth, and the Eddic Vǫluspá also names the "mistletoe" in connection with Baldr's death. No Nordic source, however, links the plant to Christmas, to Yule or to any winter custom whatsoever.
Verdict: Mistletoe in the Baldr myth: attested (Vǫluspá, Snorri). Mistletoe as Nordic Christmas decoration: unattested.
The second major source on mistletoe is not Nordic but Roman, and it concerns the Gauls. Pliny the Elder, in his Natural History (book 16, sections 249 to 251, around AD 77), describes the druids: nothing was more sacred to them than mistletoe and the tree on which it grows, provided that tree was an oak. On oaks, however, it was found only very rarely. When one was discovered, it was gathered with great ceremony on the sixth day of the moon. A priest in a white robe climbed the tree, cut the mistletoe with a golden sickle, and it was caught in a white cloth. Then two white bulls were sacrificed. The Gauls believed that a potion made from mistletoe made barren livestock fertile and was a remedy against every poison.
It is a fascinating scene, but it has to be placed correctly. Pliny is writing about Gaul, not about Germania or Scandinavia. He names no date in winter, only a day of the lunar month. The modern era made a great deal of the passage all the same. English antiquarians of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries were enthralled by the druids, and that is the route by which mistletoe became an emblem of a romantically imagined Celtic past.
Verdict: Mistletoe as a cult plant of the Gaulish druids: attested by Pliny, but Celtic rather than Nordic, and with no winter connection. The bridge from Pliny to the sprig hanging in today's living room: unattested.
The claim: After Baldr's return, Frigg declared mistletoe a symbol of love and promised a kiss to anyone standing beneath it, and that is where the English custom comes from.
Earliest evidence: For the kissing custom itself, the earliest evidence found so far is English and dates from the late eighteenth century. A song in George Colman's stage piece Two to One (printed 1784) mentions kissing under the mistletoe at Christmas time; in 1787 the London Times printed a poem on the approaching Christmas that knows the custom too. Washington Irving described it in his Sketch Book of 1819/20 as a habit of English farmhouses: the young men had the privilege of kissing the girls under the bough, plucking a berry each time, and when the berries were all gone the privilege ended. Older evidence may exist, but none has yet been securely identified.
And the Frigg story? In Gylfaginning, Baldr's story ends with his death, his funeral pyre on the ship Hringhorni, Hermóðr's vain ride to Hel and the refusal of a giantess named Þǫkk to weep for Baldr. Baldr stays with Hel and returns only after Ragnarǫk, into a renewed world. There is nothing about a return brought about by Frigg's tears, about berries formed from tears or about a promised kiss, not in Snorri, not in the Vǫluspá and not in Saxo. The tale circulates in modern Christmas books, newspaper features and websites, and it was quite obviously built after the fact to tie an eighteenth-century English custom to a Nordic myth.
Likely origin: The kissing custom arose in England, probably in the setting of the rural and domestic Christmas games of the early modern period. It owes its present spread to English and American Christmas culture of the nineteenth century.
Verdict: Kissing under the mistletoe: later (England, attested from the late eighteenth century). Frigg as the founder of the custom: a modern invention.
The claim: The decorated fir tree is a Germanic custom that celebrated the winter solstice and the evergreen persistence of life.
Earliest evidence: The trail leads not to Scandinavia but to the Upper Rhine. The best-known early record comes from Schlettstadt, today Sélestat in Alsace. In the town's account book for 1521, under St Thomas's Day, 21 December, there is an outlay of four shillings to the foresters "to guard the may-trees on St Thomas's Day" (die meyen an Sanct Thomas Tag zu hieten), that is, to watch over the trees that citizens were allowed to fetch from the town forest for the feast. In 2021 the town therefore celebrated "500 years of the Christmas tree"; the book is kept in Sélestat's Humanist Library. Note the word: the trees are called "Maien", like the greenery that was also set up in spring.
A detailed description of a decorated indoor tree comes from an anonymous Strasbourg record of about 1605. At Christmas, it says, people in Strasbourg set up fir trees in their parlours and hang them with roses cut from coloured paper, apples, wafers, tinsel and sugar. A few decades later, in a work dating from between 1642 and 1646, the Strasbourg Minster preacher Johann Conrad Dannhauer grumbled about the "Christmas or fir tree" that people put up at home: a children's game, he wrote, through which the old Christmas season was celebrated more than God's word. That shows two things. The custom was widespread in seventeenth-century Alsace, and to a strict Lutheran it was a worldly frivolity, not a suspect pagan rite.
Freiburg im Breisgau in 1419 is often cited as well: the bakers' journeymen of the Holy Spirit Hospital are said to have hung a tree with gingerbread, apples and nuts. According to church and historical accounts, there is no secure documentary source for this story, and it should be treated as a tale.
Likely origin: Scholars point to two roots. One is the paradise tree of the medieval mystery plays, performed on 24 December, the feast day of Adam and Eve; on stage stood a tree hung with apples. The other is the older custom of bringing green branches and may-boughs into houses and guild halls at New Year and on feast days. From the guild houses and burghers' parlours of Alsace and the Upper Rhine, the tree moved into Protestant middle-class families, in the eighteenth century into aristocratic houses (Goethe has it appear in "Werther" in 1774), and only in the nineteenth century into the population at large. Catholic regions followed hesitantly; by around 1900 it had spread across confessional lines.
The tree reached Scandinavia late, and as a German import. According to the Nordiska museet in Stockholm, it arrived in Sweden in the eighteenth century by way of noble families; prosperous farmers followed, and it only became general in the late nineteenth and the twentieth century. So the very region to which the custom is so readily attributed actually took it over from Germany.
Verdict: Later. The Christmas tree is an early modern custom of the Upper Rhine, recorded from 1521 and described around 1605. A Germanic or Nordic origin is unattested.
Because the tree itself has no pagan evidence, it is often given an invented pagan backstory. Three versions do the rounds most often.
Yggdrasil. The world ash of Eddic mythology, described in the Vǫluspá, in Grímnismál and by Snorri, is a cosmic tree with three roots. It is an ash, not a conifer, and no source connects it with a winter festival, with decorations, or with setting up a tree indoors. The equation "Christmas tree = Yggdrasil" is modern interpretation, not tradition. More on the myth in Yggdrasil.
Irminsul. The Royal Frankish Annals report that Charlemagne destroyed the Irminsul, a Saxon sanctuary, in 772 during the Saxon wars. What it actually was, a pillar, a tree trunk, a sacred precinct, remains unclear; in the ninth century Rudolf of Fulda described a wooden column set upright. Here too there is no link at all to winter or to Christmas. See Irminsul.
Donar's Oak. The version you read most often is that Boniface felled the sacred oak of Donar near Geismar in Hesse, that a small fir grew up in its place, and that he showed it to the heathens as a sign of Christ: the first Christmas tree. The Life of Boniface, written by his disciple Willibald a few years after Boniface's death in 754, tells of the felling of a huge oak that the heathens called the "oak of Jupiter"; Boniface had a chapel in honour of the apostle Peter built from its timber. There is not a word about a fir, about Christmas or about winter. The fir scene comes, as far as it can be traced, from "The Oak of Geismar", a story by the American writer Henry van Dyke that appeared in Scribner's Magazine in 1891 and was published as a book, "The First Christmas Tree", in 1897. From there it spread further through American schoolbooks and devotional literature. What the sources actually say about the felling is set out in Donar's Oak.
Verdict: All three connections are modern interpretations. Yggdrasil and the Irminsul were a real belief and a real sanctuary respectively, but they have nothing to do with the Christmas tree; the Boniface fir legend is a story of the late nineteenth century.
The claim: Bringing fir branches, holly or ivy into the house in winter continues a Germanic custom that celebrated life's endurance through the cold.
Earliest evidence: The earliest evidence for winter greenery comes from the Mediterranean. For the Roman New Year, the Kalends of January, people decorated houses and doors with laurel and greenery, lit lamps and exchanged gifts (strenae). Christian writers criticised this early on. Around 200, the church writer Tertullian railed in his treatise on idolatry (De idololatria 15) against Christians who decked their doors with laurel and lamps just like the heathens. In the sixth century, Bishop Martin of Braga in the north-west of the Iberian peninsula listed, in his sermon De correctione rusticorum (chapter 16), among the devil's services of the country people: keeping the Vulcanalia and the Kalends, decorating tables, setting up laurel.
Likely origin: New Year greenery is attested as Roman and Mediterranean, and it travelled across Europe together with the New Year date. In England, late medieval and early modern texts describe churches and houses being decked with holly and ivy at Christmas; the carol "The Holly and the Ivy" is a late witness to this. For the pre-Christian North, by contrast, there is no source that describes greenery at Yule. That does not mean there was none. It means nobody can claim there was.
Verdict: Winter greenery: attested, but Roman; unattested for the North.
The claim: The great log that burns in the hearth at Christmas is a survival of the Nordic Yule fire at the solstice, and the French chocolate log, the bûche de Noël, still recalls it today.
Earliest evidence: In England, the poet Robert Herrick describes the custom in his Hesperides (1648). In the poem "Ceremonies for Christmasse" he calls on his "merrie boyes" to bring the Christmas log to the fire, and advises lighting it with what is left of last year's brand. Herrick, then, already knows the idea that a piece of the wood is kept back. In France, the bûche, also known by regional names, is recorded in the folklore of many regions as a real log, often sprinkled with wine or salt; the cake version only emerged in Parisian patisseries in the nineteenth century. Among Serbs and Croats there is the badnjak, a young oak trunk or branch cut on Christmas Eve, brought into the house with ritual and burned; South Slavic folklore has described it in detail since the nineteenth century. In parts of Germany people spoke of a Christbrand or Christklotz.
Likely origin: Its spread from England through France and Germany to the Balkans shows that this is a pan-European hearth custom. Tracing it back to Scandinavia is mere guesswork. Of all places, the medieval North offers no evidence of a Yule log. The English name "Yule log" carries the old word Yule, and that has probably reinforced the impression of a Nordic origin.
Verdict: Unattested as a Nordic custom. What is attested is a Europe-wide early modern hearth custom: in England in literature from 1648, in south-eastern Europe in folklore from the nineteenth century.
The claim: The julklapp is an ancient Germanic gift custom by which people tossed each other good luck for the new year.
Earliest evidence: The word is Swedish: julklapp is still the everyday Swedish word for a Christmas present. "Klapp" refers to the knock or rap on the door. According to the Nordiska museet, on Christmas Eve you would knock at a door, throw something in, originally often a log of wood or a carved doll, frequently with a teasing verse attached, and vanish before anyone could recognise you. According to the same account, the julklapp became customary as a gift-giving practice in middle-class homes during the nineteenth century; Swedish accounts date the spread of Christmas presents in the modern sense in Sweden from the late eighteenth century.
In Germany the custom is recorded above all for Western Pomerania, Rügen and Mecklenburg, regions that partly belonged to Sweden from 1648 to 1815 or were closely tied to it. An early printed description comes from A. Kretzschmer of Anklam in the Berlinische Nachrichten von Staats- und Gelehrtensachen of 24 December 1834. On Christmas Eve, a present is hidden in one or more wrappings bearing the recipient's name, thrown in at the parlour door with a shout of "Julklapp!", and the giver makes off quickly; the recipient has to guess who it was. Wrapping in many layers, often with joking or mocking extras, is part of the game.
Likely origin: The julklapp is an early modern Swedish custom that came to Pomerania by way of Swedish rule on the southern Baltic coast. Older roots are conceivable, since begging customs and joke presents at the turn of the year are found all over Europe. A connection to the Viking Age, though, is backed by nothing at all.
Verdict: Nordic, yes, but later: a Swedish custom of the modern era, described in Pomerania from the early nineteenth century. Pagan origin: unattested.
The claim: The Swedish Lucia festival on 13 December is really a pagan festival of light for the winter solstice, with the saint merely pulled over it.
Earliest evidence: St Lucy of Syracuse is a Sicilian martyr; according to tradition she died in 304 during the persecution under Diocletian. Her name is connected with Latin lux, "light". Her feast on 13 December stood in the Swedish church calendar until the Reformation in the sixteenth century. Under the Julian calendar, that day fell close to the winter solstice in the late Middle Ages, which is the usual explanation for why Lucia Night counted in folk belief as an especially long night.
In rural Sweden this night had a dark reputation. Folklore records describe the lussenatt as dangerous, full of supernatural beings, and as a time for trying to foretell the coming year. In northern Swedish legends Lucia appears as a mountain woman who leads supernatural beings on Lucia Night. The white-clad Lucia bearing lights is something completely different. The oldest known record of her dates from 1764, from the Horn estate north of Skövde in Västergötland: a white-clad Lucia with wings and candlesticks visited the household in the morning. For a long time the custom stayed confined to western Sweden and to manor houses and middle-class families. The accompanying saffron buns, lussekatter, go back according to the Nordiska museet to a Dutch pastry that probably reached Gothenburg in the seventeenth century; saffron was only added at the end of the nineteenth century.
The breakthrough came courtesy of a newspaper. Stockholms Dagblad ran a competition and chose a Stockholm Lucia, who was driven through the city with electric candles in her crown. Most accounts, including that of the Church of Sweden, date this to 1927; the Nordiska museet gives 1928. Other newspapers copied the idea, and by the 1950s the festival was customary throughout the country, in schools, workplaces, hospitals and families. It reached Denmark only in 1944 (the first Lucia procession was staged at the National-Scala in Copenhagen), and Finland and Norway likewise in the twentieth century.
Likely origin: A Christian saint's day, linked in folk belief to the long and dangerous winter night, plus a household custom of western Swedish manors in the eighteenth century, plus a newspaper campaign of the twentieth century. That ideas about Lucia Night absorbed older winter fears is plausible. A pagan festival of light behind Lucia cannot be demonstrated.
Verdict: Later. Lucia as bringer of light is attested from 1764 and is a creation of the modern era; the eerie figures of Lucia Night are attested in folklore, but their pagan origin remains a possibility, not a finding.
The claim: Straw decorations recall pagan harvest offerings and Germanic fertility magic.
Earliest evidence: Two things need to be kept apart. One is the custom of spreading straw on the floor of the main room at Christmas. In some Swedish farming households this straw was called julglädjen, "the Christmas joy"; the Nordiska museet describes the custom without giving a starting date. It is recorded in folklore for the modern era and occurs far beyond Scandinavia, in Poland and the Baltic region for example; the Christian explanation links it to the straw of the manger. The other is the straw stars, straw crowns and straw goats familiar today as tree decorations. They presuppose the Christmas tree and therefore belong to the period in which the tree became at home in Scandinavia, the nineteenth and twentieth centuries.
Likely origin: Farm material in a farming society. That grain and straw play a part in harvest customs across Europe is beyond question; the last sheaf, harvest crowns and straw dolls are all well documented. But no straight line can be drawn from the straw star to a Germanic fertility rite. The straw Yule goat gets an article of its own.
Verdict: Straw strewn at Christmas: attested in the modern era, origin open. Straw stars as tree decorations: later (nineteenth/twentieth century).
Two customs keep turning up in lists of "pagan Christmas traditions", even though their history is fairly well known.
The goose. Roast goose as a feast-day dish is associated in central Europe above all with Martinmas on 11 November. St Martin's Day was an important date for paying rents and dues, the geese were fattened by then, and the feast of St Martin used to open a pre-Christmas fasting season, before which people ate well one last time. From there the goose also made its way onto the Christmas table. In England it remained a classic Christmas roast into the nineteenth century: in Charles Dickens's "A Christmas Carol" (1843) the Cratchit family eats goose, before the turkey later took over. There is no Nordic or pagan connection anywhere in sight; in Scandinavia, pork, lamb or fish are still more likely to be on the table.
The Advent wreath. This is one of the few customs whose origin can be dated precisely. The Protestant theologian Johann Hinrich Wichern, head of the Rauhes Haus in Hamburg, an institution for children and young people from poor backgrounds, hung up a wooden ring with candles in the prayer hall in 1839: a small red candle for every weekday from the first Sunday of Advent, a large white one for the Sundays. Fir greenery was wound round it only later, and today's four-candle form arose as a simplified version for the home. The Advent wreath reached Scandinavia in the twentieth century.
Verdict: Both later and not Nordic. The goose is central European and Christian (Martinmas); the Advent wreath is a Hamburg creation of 1839.
Several figures and customs that often appear on this list are treated in detail elsewhere on the site.
The Twelve Nights and smudging. The twelve nights between Christmas and Epiphany, the German Rauhnächte, are well documented in folklore as nights of omens and spirits, but reading them as a Germanic "time between the years" is a construction that often leans on Bede's modranecht. See Rauhnächte and Modranecht.
Lights in the dark season. Candles, torches and fires at the turn of the year are attested almost everywhere that has dark winters. No specifically Nordic custom of lights is recorded for the Viking Age; the link with the solstice is obvious, but it is a general human one.
Nisse and tomte. In folk belief the Scandinavian farm spirit gets his bowl of Christmas porridge; he only became a bringer of gifts in Sweden towards the end of the nineteenth century, when he took over from the Yule goat. See Nisse and tomte.
Father Christmas, the Wild Hunt, the Yule goat and the Yule cat. Whether Odin is hiding behind Father Christmas is examined in Odin and Father Christmas; the ghostly hosts of the winter nights are covered in The Wild Hunt in the Twelve Nights. The straw goat and the Icelandic cat that eats children without new clothes have their own articles: The Yule goat and The Yule cat.
| Custom | Earliest evidence | Origin | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| The word Yule | Gothic, 6th c.; Bede 725; skaldic poetry c. 900 | Germanic | attested Nordic/Germanic |
| Date of 25 December | Rome, Chronograph of 354 (list of 336) | Roman and Christian | not Nordic |
| Yule ale / juleøl | c. 900; Gulathing Law 11th/12th c. | Nordic, rededicated by the Church | attested Nordic |
| Julmust | Roberts, Örebro, founded 1910 | Swedish, modern | later |
| Boar / Christmas ham | boar vows in 13th-c. texts; ham mid-19th c. | slaughtering season; link to myth a hypothesis | possible |
| Mistletoe in myth | Vǫluspá; Snorri c. 1220 | Icelandic tradition | attested, but no Christmas link |
| Kissing under the mistletoe | England 1784 | English | later |
| Christmas tree | Sélestat 1521; Strasbourg c. 1605 | Upper Rhine | later |
| Winter greenery | Tertullian c. 200; Martin of Braga 6th c. | Roman New Year | unattested as Nordic |
| Yule log | Herrick 1648 | pan-European hearth custom | unattested as Nordic |
| Julklapp | Pomerania 1834; Sweden 18th/19th c. | Swedish | Nordic, but later |
| Lucia | 1764 Horn (Västergötland); Stockholm 1927 | saint's day + manor custom | later |
| Straw stars | 19th/20th c. | rural tree decoration | later |
| Christmas goose | Martinmas goose, Middle Ages | central European | not Nordic |
| Advent wreath | Hamburg 1839 | Wichern, Rauhes Haus | later |
Which Christmas custom has the most secure Nordic root? The shared festive ale. Drinking at Yule is recorded as early as around 900, and Norwegian church law expressly required Christmas ale, with a dedication formula known from pagan drinking offerings.
Did the Vikings decorate a fir tree? There is no evidence for it. The oldest secure reference to Christmas trees comes from Alsace in 1521, and the custom only reached Scandinavia from Germany in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries.
Is kissing under the mistletoe a Viking custom? No. It is recorded in England from 1784. Mistletoe does appear in the Baldr myth, but there it is the weapon that kills the god.
Where does the word julklapp come from? From Swedish: "klapp" means the knock on the door before the present was thrown in. The custom reached the German Baltic coast by way of Swedish Pomerania.
Is Lucia a pagan festival of light? That cannot be shown. Lucia is a Christian saint; the white-clad queen of light is only recorded from 1764 and became a national custom through a newspaper competition in 1927.

Jól – the Yule feast · Baldr · Nisse & Tomte · The Yule Goat – from straw goats and masked visitors to Joulupukki and the Gävle goat · The Yule Cat · Yule log and Yule fire.
All Festivals & Belief articles →
Where did the dead of the North go? Anyone who reads the old sources finds no simple answer, and certainly no single …
Read more →Between Christmas and Epiphany, people in Mecklenburg used to say, Wode passes over the land with his hounds. Leave a …
Read more →At midwinter, it is often said, the dead draw near. Is that true for the age of the Vikings and the Germanic peoples? …
Read more →For our ancestors the year was no sheet on a wall but work: sowing, herding, harvesting, storing. The festivals sat at …
Read more →